In human evolution, almost all
of the natural selection process occurred before modern cities, when our
ancestors were hunter-gatherers. The occasional mauling of tourists in
Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming pales in comparison with what very distant
ancestors had to contend with, hence the need-turned-instinct to keep the
present and the immediate foremost in a human’s constricted consciousness. It
is no wonder, therefore, that we unconsciously assume as a matter of course
that our present world—the context in which we exist—is foundational and serves
as the default for our judgments and conclusions. We tend not to realize that what
is important in the society and age in which we live has not always been important.
Christmas is a good example. For
example, were we to travel back in time to early nineteenth-century Europe (or
at the very least to London), we would find that Christmas was regarded as a
minor holiday without any hint of the elongated retail-season that has become so
salient in the E.U. and U.S. each November and December, eclipsing and even in
some cases blatantly ignoring Thanksgiving in the case of the U.S. (which
should therefore probably move that holiday to October 12th, when
Canadians observe the same holiday). How Christmas became such a major holiday,
at least in Europe and the Americas, is the subject of the 2017 film, The ManWho Invented Christmas. That man was Charles Dickens, and the vehicle was
his best-selling novel, A Christmas Carol. The meaning of Christmas in
that story is echoed in Dickens’s own arc in the film, so audiences are treated
to an uncovering of the holiday’s pristine and unmolested core. To be sure, what
Charles sees as the main values being evinced and honored in Christmas both in
his book and his life can still be recognized, and surprisingly neither in the
commercial holiday nor the explicitly religious one.
At the end of the film, when
Charles and his extended family are celebrating Christmas at home, he must
explain why an evergreen tree is in the parlor. He says the Germans have them,
and call them “tannenbaums.” Baum means
tree auf Deutsch. The British royal family, which was headed then by
Queen Victoria, included the German Prince Albert, had a tannenbaum, so the
custom, Charles tells his family, is quickly becoming all the rage in London (spreading
like wildfire would not convey the same idea!).[1]
“It is a Christmas—tree,” Charles says by deliberately pausing between the two
words, and tis, plus his tone of voice, conveys to audiences that the term was
new in 1843, when the film takes place.
By implication, Charles’
conception of the meaning of Christmas is pristine, rather than being impacted
by exogenous elements interlarded over decades by outside forces such as retail
corporations. Charles’ grasp of what Christmas really is all about is of course
in his book, which as mentioned in the film hit bookstores a week before
Christmas and was sold out by Christmas Day. The film leaves us with the strong impression
that the book would drastically heighten the significance of a holiday that had
clearly been a minor one that did not even include Christmas trees. Therefore, the
film puts viewers at the very point when Christmas was on the verge of becoming
very popular, and even provides what drew millions of people to celebrate the holiday:
Dickens’ insight into the core meaning of Christmas.
So, the meaning that Charles brings out of Christmas in the book he is writing,
and, in a parallel way, which the film itself associates with Charles’ character
arc, is foundational for Christmas, rather than being a dilution or softening
of a pre-extant retail or an overtly theological original meaning.
Our leanings interlaced in our
very nature through a myriad of human generations to privilege our immediate
context, and therefore our conceptions of Christmas, need to be
bracketed, or resisted, so we can enter Dickens’ world set in 1843. Just after
the final scene has ended, the film informs its audience in screen-text that
charitable giving soared in Britain after the publication of A Christmas Carol.
No one is useless, Charles says in the film, who lightens the heavy burdens
being carried by others. In the book, Tiny Tim does not die after all because
Scrooge’s new-found spirit of generosity has lightened Bob Cratchit’s burden of
Tim’s illness. Being rich does not in itself render a person useful; having a
soul of kindness and generosity is requisite. Even though wealth helps in being
able to lighten another person’s burden—Tim would certainly die without Scrooge’s
beneficence—a poor person can assume a lightening role too.
In the film, Charles leverages
his imaginary character, Scrooge, whose transformation triggers that of Charles
himself. Before Charles places Scrooge literally in Scrooge’s own grave to turn
up the pressure on the incorrigible old man to change, Charles has kicked out
his impoverished parents because his dad had lied to him about needing to be in
London to do research for a piece to be purchased by a publication. In putting
Scrooge in a grave “pressure-cooker” of sorts to trigger an internal reckoning
with a inevitable death without having been of any real usefulness, however,
Charles too gains “hope in our higher natures” and can feel the joy of “friendship,
kindness, and generosity.” What he wants so much in his character, and gets in
himself as a result, is a “soul of kindness and generosity.” This is precisely what
Christmas means, values, and celebrates; it lies at the core of the holiday,
and is why Christmas became a major holiday with the publication of A Christmas
Carol, by which means Dickens exposed the underlying jewel of Christmas in
1843.
Interestingly, no Christian
theology regarding Christ is in the film’s screenplay. To be sure, Jesus of the
Gospels instantiates a soul of kindness and generosity—extending compassionate
acts even to Romans, to the consternation of the Zionist zealots like Judas. Even
the claim that December 25th marks Jesus Christ’s birthday cannot be
collaborated by historians, and the claim conflates two qualitatively different
writing genres—historical accounts and faith narratives. Theologically, Jesus’s
birth in a manger in the Gospels is not miraculous; the Incarnation miracle of God
becoming flesh is celebrated in the Annunciation feast-day (March 25 by the
Roman Church), rather than on Christmas. As for that holiday, The Man Who
Invented Christmas does not explicitly derive the meaning of Christmas from
a focus on Jesus; rather, the audience is left to make the connection. In the
film, Dickens’ perspective is wider than one oriented to dogma along specific
metaphysical and supernatural tenets, for the writer embraces and celebrates a
soul—any soul—that is of kindness and generosity, and thus feels joy in these
and friendship. Charles does not derive his understanding of what Christmas is
really about from Christology or the Incarnational agape love of God
even though those specifically Christian theological doctrines are consistent
with the type of soul that is saturated with kindness and generosity. A reader
of A Christmas Carol, and a viewer of the film on Charles writing that
book, need not subscribe to any theological doctrines of Christianity. This
fits with the popularity that the holiday would gain in the 20th
century, outstripping Christianity itself.
Given the separation of Church and State in the U.S. Constitution, an official national (and state) holiday cannot be the religious version. Detractors of Christmas, who essentially instantiate pre-transformed-Scrooge vitriol and garden-variety jealousy against Christians, had by 2020 made shaming souls of kindness and generosity for saying “Merry Christmas” a salient part of the ideological “politically-correct” fad. Going back to the what Christmas is about in A Christmas Carol and for Charles himself in the film (i.e., the role that Christmas plays in his character arc) shows just how mistaken (and disturbed) it is to claim that Jesus must be at the center of Christmas. In the film, Christmas to Charles lies in his outlay of generosity to his parents when he invites them back to live in his apartment shortly before the holiday. “Who else can make Christmas pudding?” he asks his mother. The thick viscosity of pudding renders it a fitting symbol for an on-going stay.
Americans who intentionally replace saying “Merry Christmas” with “Happy Holidays” (not even willing to narrow it down to a holiday), or, with even more passive aggression, “Enjoy your holiday” out of the mistaken belief that a person must subscribe to Jesus being the incarnate Son of God in order to celebrate or even observe Christmas can thus be seen as off base. The examples of billions and billions of non-Christians in India and China who exchange presents under Christmas trees because of the inherent value felt to lie in kindness and generosity, undercut the claim that Christmas is only, or must be, a holiday for Christians or is a Christian holiday. So too do Dicken’s classic book, A Christmas Carol, and the film that tells the story of Charles’ writing of that book.
Valuing a soul, which anyone, even Scrooge, can have, that
is constituted by kindness and generosity, finding usefulness in being able to
lighten others’ burdens, and getting in touch with the associated joy of
friendship are not exclusively Christian because subscription to a particular theological
is not necessary. Only a pathetic, pathological, and utterly stubborn Scrooge with
a hardened heart would unleash passive aggression to try to block or unilaterally
forbid any public mention specifically of Christmas itself, as if it being an
official legal holiday did not render saying “Merry Christmas” in public entirely
valid. In 2026, Dickens’ tale would again be released in movie theatres, though
unfortunately I suspect without many viewers making the connection between the
anti-Christmas passive-aggressive imposing-by-hostility in their own day
and Johnny Depp’s pre-transformed Ebenezer.
[1] When
I was a teenager, one year just after Christmas I had the bright idea to toss the
evergreen that had been twisting up the staircase rail at home into the fire in
the fireplace rather than put the dried greenery in a plastic yard bag. The
inside of the chimney caught on fire, and the fire department had to come. I
told my brother it was a good thing I did not try to dispose of the Christmas
tree that way!